The Kind of Longing That Doesn’t Announce Itself A quiet return is rarely just about the place There is a certain kind of longing that doesn't arrive loudly or demand to be resolved. It lingers quietly, almost respectfully, as if it knows it doesn't need your immediate attention to exist. I felt something similar while reading The Green Book: An Observer's Notebook by Amitava Kumar , where he returns to his hometown after his father's death. There is no dramatic attempt to reclaim what was lost, no urgency to extract meaning from memory. Instead, there is a stillness in the way he moves through familiar spaces, as though he is not searching for something specific, yet remains open to whatever the place might still hold. And perhaps that is what stayed with me the most—not the return itself, but the unspoken question beneath it: what exactly are we looking for when we go back? The Illusion of Returning Familiar spaces cannot recreate past versions of us Think of a p...
There’s a moment in life—quiet, heavy, almost suffocating—when everything narrows down to one question: “Why me?” Not loudly. Not dramatically. But internally. Repeatedly. Relentlessly. It shows up when life doesn’t go as planned. When something cracks open your sense of control. When the story you thought you were living suddenly rewrites itself without your permission. A breakup. A diagnosis. A betrayal. A loss. A failure. And in that moment, you don’t want philosophy. You don’t want advice. You just want an answer. Why me? When Dante Asked the Same Question While reading Canto II of Dante’s Inferno , I stumbled upon something deeply human—something that didn’t feel like poetry or literature, but like a mirror. Before Dante begins his journey into Hell, he hesitates. He stops. Doubts himself. Questions everything. And then he turns to Virgil and essentially asks: Why me? I am no one. Why am I chosen for this? Think about that. Dante isn’t standing a...